An Artist Reports on the Future of Europe

Ukraine Protest

Left: Ukrainian antigovernment protesters on Independence Square in Kiev, Dec. 10, 2013. Right: Dinner setting for “New Narrative for Europe” conference, Palazzo Clerici, Milan, Dec. 09, 2013.

We the outsiders at the gates of EU officialdom—the perennial emigrants, the wandering Jews—believe in Europe and all its bureaucratic trappings. Just ask our Ukrainian friends at Euromaidan Square, or our Iranian colleagues in the Green Movement, which sprung up after the contested 2009 presidential elections. So as an Iranian-Texan Russophile, I was duly delighted to attend the “New Narrative for Europe” conference this past weekend at Milan’s Palazzo Clerici, a grandiose 18th-century manor. Even more so when I received the brief in advance and discovered its emphasis on 1989 and 2008 as key years, two of the three dates (with 1979) that the art collective Slavs and Tatars looked at closely within the pages of 032c (issues 17 and 18). Artists (Olafur Eliasson, Andrea Büttner, Jimmie Durham), scholars, thinkers (Stefano Boeri, Czesław Porębski, Nicola Setari), economists, and politicians had been invited to discuss how culture could step in to fill an urgent gap—be it emotional, affective, or aspirational—left by the politicians’ unfortunate, if excessive, reliance on the rational and the economic.

If the older EU generation’s motto was “Never Again” (referring to war on the continent after 1945), the younger generation’s seems to be a more equivocal “Come Again?” Those born in the 1980s or later often take the EU’s landmark achievements—freedom of movement, a single currency, freedom of work (in the rare pockets one still finds employment, of course)—for granted. They simply don’t remember it being any other way. Of course, there’s no shortage of bricks to throw at the Union’s often aseptic façade: the EU’s inability to avert the tragedy of the Yugoslav war(s), the fetishization of economic growth, the inability to integrate (postcolonial) immigration, etc. But we’re equally spoiled with feats, even if less newsworthy: a robust, if teetering, welfare state, the only among the heavyweights of Russia, China, the US; no death penalty; women’s rights; a relatively strong record on environmental policy; to name just a few.

But how do you come up with a narrative without a counter-narrative? Nobody wants a negative sales pitch, just ask advertisers. Without fail, every national narrative is somehow conceived, drafted, or understood vis-à-vis the identification of an “enemy,” no matter how vague or concrete. What’s clear is that ideas have outsides (and insides of course) and this particular idea—a union of 27, and soon 28, member states, with a troubled history to say the least—cannot be considered without its reverse, its margins, its outsides. Our small committee—which included Michelangelo Pistoletto, the Prada Foundation’s Germano Celant and the Van Abbemuseum’s Charles Esche— kept coming back to the notion of emancipation. Equally immaterial and material, emancipation offers freedom but not the star-spangled variety. Emancipation from what then is the question? Perhaps the burden of history, from Big Data, our own complacency, or perhaps the need for specificity itself.

We presented our thoughts to the President of the European Commission, José Manuel Barroso, who has been the driving force behind the New Narrative initiative. Refreshingly (and rather surprisingly for a politician), he seemed to embrace the otherwise complex notion of indeterminacy at the heart of the European project, even ending his short speech with a line from U2’s “Zooropa”: “Don’t worry baby / It’s gonna be alright / Uncertainty can be a guiding light.”

Deeper

  • 032c Cosmic Workshop Collection

    032c Cosmic Workshop Belt

    €170
    Buy Now
  • 032c Cosmic Workshop Collection

    032c COSMIC WORKSHOP "Maria" Longsleeve Grey

    €90
    Buy Now
  • Life Exists: Theaster Gates’ Black Image Corporation

    Theaster Gates' “The Black Image Corporation” presents photographs from the holdings of Chicago’s Johnson Publishing Company, a sprawling archive that shaped “the aesthetic and cultural languages of contemporary African American identity.” Gates approached the project as a celebration and activation of the black image in Milan through photographs of women photographed by Moneta Sleet Jr. and Isaac Sutton – of black entrepreneurship and legacy-making. “Life exists” in the Johnson archive, he says, just as it exists and should be honored in other places of black creativity.More
  • FRIDA ESCOBEDO: The Era of the Starchitect is Over

    Rising Mexican architect Frida Escobedo is relentlessly inquisitive, eschewing stylistic constants in favour of an overriding preoccupation with shifting dynamics. Personal curiosity is the driving force behind her practice, which makes he an outlier in a profession dominated by extroverted personalities keen on making bold assertions. "I think it really is a generational shift," Escobedo says. "The idea of the starchitect making grand gestures with huge commissions is over."More
  • “I live a hope despite my knowing better”: James Baldwin in Conversation With Fritz J. Raddatz (1978)

    Born in Berlin in 1931, editor and writer Fritz J. Raddatz relied on food delivered by African American GIs after the death of his parents. To Baldwin he was an “anti-Nazi German who has the scars to prove it.” Debating his return to the USA after 25 years, Baldwin explores the political climate in America at the end of the 1970s in a conversation at home in Saint-Paul-de-Vence.More
  • House as Archive: James Baldwin’s Provençal Home

    For her new book, Magdalena J. Zaborowska visited the house Baldwin occupied from 1971 to 1987 “to expand his biography and explore the politics and poetics of blackness, queerness, and domesticity”. Here, she narrates her early journeys to Baldwin’s home and proposes a salve for its recent loss: a virtual presentation of Baldwin’s home and effects.More
  • Where are the real investments? Theaster Gates on James Baldwin

    The Chicago-based artist talks to Victoria Camblin about materializing the past, the house as museum, and preserving black legacies. Social and artistic engagement, Gates suggests, may allow the contents and spirit of Baldwin’s home, and others like it, to settle in lived experience.More